Managing Coastal Processes: Costs, Benefits and Conflicting Views

Summary Flashcards Quiz

Edexcel B GCSE Geography > The UK’s Evolving Physical Landscape > Managing Coastal Processes: Costs, Benefits and Conflicting Views

Managing the coast is essential to protect people, property and the environment from erosion and flooding. However, not all coastlines can be protected equally. There are different approaches to managing coastal landscapes, each with its own costs, benefits and consequences.

Hard Engineering Strategies

Hard engineering involves building man-made structures to resist the power of the sea.

Strategy	Description	Benefits	Costs & Conflicts
Sea Walls	Tall concrete walls sometimes with a curved top to reflect wave energy.	Highly effective against erosion and flooding; long-term protection.	Expensive to build and maintain; visually intrusive; restrict beach access.
Groynes	Wooden or stone barriers at right angles to the beach that trap sediment.	Build up beaches, offering protection; relatively cheap.	Starve beaches further down the coast of sediment; can affect tourism and walking access.

Hard engineering is often employed in economically valuable areas, such as cities or power stations (e.g., Easington gas terminal). However, it can cause problems downstream where erosion increases due to interrupted sediment flow.

Soft Engineering Strategies

Soft engineering works in conjunction with natural processes to manage the coast, making it a more environmentally sustainable approach.

Strategy	Description	Benefits	Costs & Conflicts
Beach replenishment	Sand or shingle is added to beaches from elsewhere.	Absorbs wave energy; maintains natural appearance.	Must be repeated regularly; expensive over time; may damage seabed ecosystems.
Slope stabilisation	Planting vegetation or re-grading cliffs to reduce mass movement.	Reduces landslides and erosion risk; blends into landscape.	Less effective in high-energy environments; limited to suitable geology.

Soft engineering is usually cheaper and visually more appealing, but may not offer full protection during extreme storms.

Sustainable Approaches to Coastal Management

Modern strategies focus on sustainability and long-term planning, including:

1. Do Nothing
Allowing natural processes to occur without interference.
✅ No cost
❌ High risk to property and people

2. Managed Retreat (Strategic Realignment)
Deliberately allowing certain areas to flood or erode by removing defences.
✅ Creates new habitats like salt marshes
❌ Controversial — land, homes and livelihoods may be lost

These options are more viable in low-value or sparsely populated areas.

Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM)

ICZM is a holistic approach that considers the whole coastal system — human, physical and ecological — across long stretches known as coastal cells.

It aims to:

Combine hard and soft engineering
Balance environmental, economic and social needs
Involve all stakeholders (residents, businesses, conservationists)

This approach recognises that coastal processes do not stop at town boundaries and that defending one place often affects another.

Why Is There Conflict?

Economic: Expensive defences may only protect a few homes
Environmental: Structures can damage ecosystems and landscapes
Social: Local people may oppose managed retreat
Political: Pressure to protect tourist resorts or infrastructure

Coastal managers must weigh up costs and benefits, local needs, and long-term sustainability when choosing the right strategy.

Summary

Types of Management
Coastal management includes hard engineering (e.g. sea walls, groynes), soft engineering (e.g. beach replenishment), and sustainable approaches like managed retreat.
Hard Engineering
Uses structures like sea walls and groynes to resist wave power. Effective but expensive, visually intrusive, and can disrupt sediment flow elsewhere.
Soft Engineering
Works with natural processes (e.g. dune planting, beach replenishment). Cheaper and more sustainable, but may be less effective during storms.
Managed Retreat
Involves allowing areas to flood or erode naturally. Creates salt marshes but can be controversial due to land loss and relocation costs.
Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM)
Manages whole coastal areas as coastal cells, aiming to balance environmental, economic, and social needs using a combination of strategies.
Conflict and Decision Making
Different stakeholders may disagree on which areas to protect, especially when funding is limited or nature conservation conflicts with development.