Hard Engineering Coastal Management

AQA GCSE Geography > Physical Landscapes in the UK > Coastal Landscapes in the UK > Hard Engineering Coastal Management

Hard engineering coastal management involves building artificial structures that control natural processes.

Hard engineering approaches to coastal management tend to be expensive, have a short lifespan, and are visually unappealing and unsustainable. They often increase erosion in other places further down the coast.

The image below illustrates a range of hard engineering strategies implemented at Hornsea, on the Holderness Coast.

Sea defences at Hornsea

Groynes

Groynes are wooden barriers constructed at right angles to the beach to retain the material. The beach material, including sand and pebbles, is trapped between groynes and cannot be transported away by longshore drift. Groynes encourage a wide beach that helps absorb energy from waves, reducing the rate of cliff erosion. The photograph below illustrates the difference in how far waves travel inland when sediment is trapped by a groyne, thereby raising the beach’s height.

A groyne at Hornsea on the Holderness Coast

Advantages of groynes

Social

Groynes act as windbreaks for people on the beach
Groynes do not affect access to the beach.

Economic

At around £ 5,000 each, they are relatively inexpensive, and if well-maintained, they can last 40 years.
They are much cheaper to repair than other hard engineering solutions.
A wide, sandy beach attracts tourists, which benefits the local economy.

Disadvantages of groynes

Environmental

Groynes do not look attractive.

Social

Groynes act as a barrier which impedes people walking along a beach
The beach on the downdrift side of the groyne can be much lower than the up-drift side. This can make them very dangerous, particularly for young children. At Hornsea on the Holderness Coast, there is a height difference of almost 2m between the beach on either side of one groyne.

Economic

Beaches downdrift of the defences are starved of beach material due to their impact on longshore drift. This leads to increased erosion, which has an economic impact further along the coast.
Groynes need regular maintenance.
Groynes are ineffective during storm conditions.

Approximate Cost

Typically around £5000 each

Sea Walls

Seawalls are usually built along the front of cliffs to protect settlements or other areas of high economic importance. They are often recurved, which means waves are reflected back on themselves. This can cause the erosion of material at the base of the seawall.

Recurved sea wall and rock armour at Scarborough

The video below shows the sea wall at Scarborough.

Advantages of sea walls

Social

A sea wall gives people a sense of safety and security.
Sea walls often have promenades on top of them, which are popular with tourists.

Economic

Sea walls have a long lifespan and provide excellent defence where wave energy is large.

Environmental

Sea walls do not impede the movement of sediment along the coast by longshore drift.

Disadvantages of sea walls

Social

Sea walls can affect access to the beach.
Coastal flooding can occur when waves overtop (break over) the sea wall.

Economic

Sea walls are costly to construct and maintain. The UK Government is investing £30m in a new sea wall in Dawlish, Devon, to protect the mainline railway after it collapsed during storms on 4 February 2014.
Reflected waves scour the beach and can cause foundations to be undermined.

Environmental

Recurved sea walls can increase the erosion of beach material.
Sea walls do not look attractive.
Sea walls destroy habitats.
Sea walls affect the coastal system and reduce the input of sediment.

Approximate Cost

£5000/m

Revetments

Traditionally, these have been wooden slatted barriers constructed towards the rear of beaches to protect the base of cliffs. Waves breaking against the revetments dissipate energy.

A wood revetment at Sheringham on the Norfolk coast.

Concrete revetments have recently been used in places such as Hornsea.

Advantages of revetments

Social

Revetments do not impede people from walking along a beach

Economic

Cheaper and less intrusive than a sea wall.

Environmental

Less beach material is eroded compared to a sea wall.

Disadvantages of revetments

Social

Revetments can impede access to the beach.

Economic

A short lifespan (mainly when constructed from wood) and unsuitable where wave energy is high.

Environmental

Revetments do not look attractive.
Revetments destroy habitats.
Revetments affect the coastal system and reduce the input of sediment.

Approximate Cost

£2000/m

Rock Armour

Rock armour is a barrier of large boulders placed before a cliff or sea wall to absorb wave energy and reduce backwash by encouraging percolation.

Advantages of rock armour

Social

It does not impede access along the beach (unless it is used as a gabion).

Economic

At £1000 to £3000, it is cheaper than constructing a sea wall.
The structure is quick and easy to construct. It can be built in weeks rather than months, reducing the economic impact of its installation.
If it is well maintained, it will last for years.
It is versatile because it can be placed before a sea wall, extending its life span. It can also stabilise slopes on dunes.

Environmental

Rock armour does not impede sediment movement along the coast by longshore drift.

Disadvantages of rock armour

Social

Access to the beach is difficult as beach access is limited.

Economic

Costs increase when the rock is imported.

Environmental

Rock armour looks unattractive.
Rock has to be quarried, which can cause environmental damage.

Approximate Cost

£1000 to £3000/m

Gabions

Gabions are wire mesh cages filled with pebbles or rocks. They are placed at the back of sandy beaches. As water enters the cages, wave energy is absorbed and dissipated.

The image below shows a gabion.

Coastal erosion defences in the form of interlocking concrete blocks in the foreground and stone-filled wired gabion baskets behind

Advantages of gabions

Social

It does not impede access along the beach

Economic

At around £110 a metre, they are cheap and easy to construct
The structure is quick to build and cheap to maintain
For the cost, they are a good value for money as they can last between 20-25 years

Environmental

Gabions do not impede sediment movement along the coast by longshore drift.
They blend in better than most other hard engineering solutions. This is especially the case when sand is blown over them or when they are covered by vegetation.

Disadvantages of gabions

Social

Access to the beach is difficult as people may have to climb over the rock armour or make detours.
In a damaged state, gabions are very dangerous.

Economic

Gabions are restricted to sandy beaches as material thrown at them on shingle beaches would quickly degrade them.

Environmental

Damaged gabions are unsightly and dangerous to sea birds.

Breakwater

These are large concrete blocks and boulders located offshore to change the direction of waves and reduce longshore drift. They also help absorb wave energy.